What the Church Can Learn From Starbucks’ Bold Stance on Gay Marriage
This past week during Starbucks’ annual shareholders meeting CEO Howard Shultz shut down an investor, who asked if the company’s support of a gay marriage initiative in Washington state was to blame for a disappointing earnings season.
Shultz responded, “some things are not a ﬁnancial decision.” His bold words brought immediate applause from the other shareholders. Shultz then added that if the investor didn’t like the company’s position, he was welcome to “sell your shares … and buy shares in another company. Thank you very much.”
Shultz’s comments were celebrated in the meeting however days later those same remarks created a ﬁrestorm in the Evangelical community as calls to “Dump Starbucks” began going viral across the internet. It is surprising to see the shock my fellow Christian coffee addicts are displaying at the moment. This is not a new position for the company, it is just the boldest they’ve stated it to date.
I strongly oppose Starbucks’ position of “marriage equality.” But I can respect the fact that they are willing to hurt their own bottom line rather than compromise their convictions. Imagine the possibilities if every Christian leader would do the same. Is there something we can learn from a company willing to put principles before proﬁts? I
believe there is…
Some Things Are Not a Financial Decision
Don’t miss the signiﬁcance of Shultz’s statement. Starbucks is in business to make money, but in the past few years the company has chosen to invest their inﬂuence and resources to simultaneously champion causes. They do it because they believe it’s the right thing to do, and some things are not a ﬁnancial decision.
True Christian leaders understand that every decision is ﬁrst and foremost a spiritual decision, not a ﬁnancial one. Our ﬁrst question should never be, “How much is this going to cost?” Yes, cost is an important question, but it’s not the most important one. The ﬁrst question should be, “What is right?” This is a spiritual question that leads a
leader to make spiritual decisions. It requires you to search Scripture for God’s principles, it requires you to invest time on your knees to get a clear word from the Lord so that you can say, “This is what God has said.” I’ve been in more meetings than I care to admit where we were asking the wrong questions at ﬁrst. It’s so easy to fall into
the trap of being led by “how much?” when you haven’t ﬁrst determined “what’s right?”
Increasingly, churches are having to count the costs associated with taking bold stances. A good friend of mine was invited to minister in a city on the west coast. On his way to the church from the airport the pastor instructed him not to preach against homosexuality. The church had already faced tremendous persecution from the gay community in their area and was fearful of the costs to their congregation. They had been intimidated into a position of silence.
More and more, ministers are feeling pressure to tone down their message. They are fearful that preaching the hard truth may threaten the church’s 501c3 status, that tithes and offerings will decline or that they may lose their standing within the community. The cost is too great to jeopardize the ministry over divisive moral issues. But, isn’t that exactly where the church is needed most? Now is not the time for the city set upon the hill to extinguish our light. This nation needs our voice!
Leaders justify the silence saying, “this is an issue we have chosen not to focus on.”
They remind their members that the church is supposed to be a house full of compassion and that the best way to win is with our love.
This is only half true. The church is at its best when it is full of COMPASSION and full of CONVICTION. That is the example Jesus set. He was unconditional in His love and He was unwavering in his conviction. It was His love that drew the multitudes, and it was His convictions that drove them away. His radical commitment to both changed the
There is a cost to doing what is right. Especially when the prevailing winds of public opinion are blowing against you. Starbucks has polling data on their side. The church is now ﬁnding many of it’s convictions on the opposite side of that ﬁght. Are we willing to put our money where our mouth is and stand up for what we know is right?
Sell Your Shares
Shultz added if you don’t like our position then “sell your shares.” He made it clear, that they will not compromise their convictions to keep you in their company. It is time spiritual leaders do the same!
Consider how different their approach is to the one we are watching play out with the Boy Scouts of America. LGBT groups are calling for boycotts, companies are pulling their funding, and the secular media is keeping them in the spotlight. The outside pressure has forced the organization into an internal debate that has dragged on for
months. What if the Boy Scouts had said, “This is who we are, if you don’t like it, ‘sell your shares’.” That position wouldn’t have been political, but it would have been principled. In some ways, the Scouts have already lost because they’ve proven that their convictions are open for debate. They will change, it may not be this year, but it will happen. The fact we are watching the discussion means they’ve already shown they’re willing to compromise.
Convictions are a vital part of your core. Changing them is impossible because it means changing everything. I admire churches and leaders who are unapologetic in their values. They refuse to give an inch even when potential donors tempt them with large checks attached to preconditions. They make it clear, you can keep your money, we will keep our convictions. If the church compromises today, it will be irrelevant tomorrow.
Why This Matters
I am a ﬁrm believer that the role of the church in society is one of transformation. However there is a shift taking place. Businesses are no longer staying out of the public debate on moral issues. Growing their brand is not their sole focus, they are looking to advance their cause as well. Corporations like Starbucks are now signiﬁcantly shaping
the culture around us. Are we passing this opportunity to corporations because we have become too focused on growing our own brands? I’m simply posing the question.
What would happen if the entire body of Christ became united and spoke with one voice concerning what is right? Imagine what a difference that could have made this past week. What were we doing as the Supreme Court was hearing arguments that could set precedent to redeﬁne the biblical deﬁnition of marriage. This week the biggest
headlines came from a secular company, taking an unapologetic secular stance on the issue. Where was the voice of the church?
Have we heeded the advice of some Christian leaders and recognized we are on the “wrong side” of the issue and it’s time to “adapt or die”? Are we adopting a position of silence? Have we counted the cost and decided its not worth ﬁghting for?
Marriage is a sacred issue before it is a state issue. If the church chooses not to use its voice at this time, we leave God’s gift of marriage in the hands of politicians, political action groups and lobbyists. Church if we are complacent at this time America becomes the casualty of our compromise.
It’s time to learn a lesson from Starbucks. They’ve found conviction alongside their coffee and caffeine. Perhaps we can as well.